Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
I tell you the details and the story for interesting crimes from across Canada, with insights that only a retired RCMP officer can provide. Finally, a Canadian true crime podcast that is interesting on more than one level.
My podcasts are the best version of true crime, where you get the juicy details of the story, but also an understanding of what was happening in the minds of police investigators as they're working the case, and how certain pieces of evidence can solve the case. I also do my best to paint a picture of the day or life of the unsuspecting victim.
Just don't listen to a story of what happened, try and feel what it felt like for those involved.
Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
The $14 Trap - BC Payday Lenders are Held Accountable
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
At 11:47 am on November 12, 2025, a BC borrower got a text from an online lender: “Your file will be presented to RCMP, CRA and provincial crime units. Payment is the ONLY abort code. Financial annihilation imminent.” There was no protocol, and the RCMP was not coming.
In this episode, I look at payday lending in British Columbia through the regulator’s own files. A Fort St. John storefront wrote loans to parents living on the Canada Child Benefit, setting each one to come due 1 to 3 days before their next cheque. A lender with 8 branches across the Interior and Vancouver Island wrote 391 Christmas loans to people on social assistance in 15 days, without telling them the loans were high-cost. And in Surrey, Toledo Credit’s collectors told struggling borrowers they faced fraud charges, prison, and “reputational destruction.”
From a retired RCMP officer’s point of view, I explain why this industry exists, why it’s regulated, the harm it can do, and the rules every borrower should know before they sign, including who to call when a lender crosses the line.
www.canadiancrimecast.com
THE $14 TRAP: PAYDAY LENDERS, DEBT COLLECTORS, AND THE PEOPLE WHO BORROW FROM THEM
A note before we start. This episode is a little different. There is no body, no crime scene tape, no jury. But there are victims, there are people who broke the law, and there are investigators who caught them. If you have ever been short on rent 3 days before payday, or had a collector call your work, this one is for you.
INTRO
It is November 12, 2025. You live in BC. You borrowed money online from a company called Toledo Credit and you fell behind. At 11:47 in the morning, your phone buzzes. The text reads, in full:
"Multi-jurisdictional enforcement protocol activated. Your file will be presented to RCMP, CRA and provincial crime units. Payment is the ONLY abort code. Financial annihilation imminent."
Nothing in that message was true. There was no protocol. The RCMP was not coming. There is no such thing as a provincial crime unit that takes debtor files. It was written to make a frightened person pay.
Now go back 3 years. It is December 2022. You are on social assistance in Prince George, or Kelowna, or Nanaimo. Christmas is 10 days away and the cheque does not come until January. You walk into a storefront lender and sign a contract for something called a "Lift Loan." The paper says the term is 1 month. It does not say the words "high-cost." It does not tell you this is a payday loan, or that you already have one with this same company, which means legally this second loan should never have been written.
391 people signed that contract in 15 days.
This is a story about a corner of Canadian finance most people never think about until they are standing inside it. Payday loans. Debt collection. The companies that sell it, the people who buy it, and the small provincial regulator in Burnaby that is supposed to keep it honest. I spent a career in the RCMP. I have been in a lot of living rooms where the money had run out. So I want to explain why this industry exists, why we regulate it, and what happens when the rules get broken.
This is Canadian CrimeCast. Let's get into it.
CHAPTER 1: WHY PAYDAY LOANS EXIST
Let me start with the uncomfortable part. Payday loans exist because the demand is real.
Picture the customer. They have a job, or a benefit cheque, or both. The money arrives on a schedule and life does not. The car dies on the 9th. The hydro bill is due on the 12th. Payday is the 15th. A bank will not lend $400 for 6 days to someone with a thin credit file. The credit card is maxed. Family is tapped out, or you are too embarrassed to ask.
The payday lender fills that gap. No credit check. Cash in 15 minutes. Bring a pay stub, a bank statement and ID, sign, and walk out. The loan is secured by nothing except your next paycheque, through a pre-authorized debit.
In BC, the law defines it precisely: a loan of $1,500 or less, for 62 days or less, repaid by post-dated cheque or pre-authorized debit. Remember that definition. One of the companies in this episode built a whole product on the belief that it did not apply to them.
The cost is what makes this industry what it is. A BC payday lender can charge up to $14 for every $100 borrowed. So a $500 loan costs $70 to carry for 2 weeks. Manageable on paper. Work it out as an annual rate and you are in the hundreds of percent.
And people are using it. In 2024, 122,901 people in BC took out a payday loan, borrowing roughly $364 million. That was up 11% from the year before. Consumer Protection BC's own spokesperson put it plainly: these loans attract under-resourced consumers because there is no credit check, and a lot of them get caught in a cycle and go deeper and deeper into debt.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: I want to be fair, because it is easy to make the lender the villain in the first 5 minutes. When I was on the road I met plenty of people for whom a $300 payday loan was the difference between keeping the lights on and losing the apartment. The product is not evil. The problem is structural. The customer base is, by definition, people who are already short. A product that costs $14 per $100 every 2 weeks, sold to people who are already short, has a built-in tendency to make them shorter. That is not a conspiracy. It is arithmetic. The regulator's job is to keep that arithmetic from becoming a trap.
CHAPTER 2: WHY THEY ARE REGULATED
Here is something that surprises most people. For a long time, payday lending in Canada was technically a crime.
Section 347 of the Criminal Code makes it an offence to charge more than 60% a year in interest and fees. $14 per $100 for 2 weeks blows past that. Through the 1990s and early 2000s the industry grew in a legal grey zone, with lenders arguing their fees were not "interest" and prosecutors mostly leaving it alone.
In 2007, Parliament carved payday loans out of the criminal rate, but only in provinces that set up their own licensing and consumer protection regime. The federal government told the provinces: if you want this industry in your backyard, you police it.
BC took the deal. It wrote rules into the Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act, which I will call the BPCPA, and a Payday Loans Regulation. Every file in this episode turns on one of these rules:
- Every contract must state the actual term, must say the loan is "high-cost," must list the borrower's remedies, and must include a paragraph saying payday lending is regulated by the Province, with the regulator's contact information.
- A lender can never issue a new payday loan to someone who already has one outstanding. One at a time.
- Receipts must be given immediately and kept for 2 years.
- And the big one. If a borrower is on their third or subsequent loan within 62 days, the lender must spread repayment over at least 2 pay periods, or 3 if the borrower is paid bi-weekly or more often, with caps on how big each instalment can be.
That last rule is aimed straight at the debt cycle. The legislature recognized that someone on their third loan in 2 months is not using the product as designed. They are using it to survive. So the law forces the lender to give that person breathing room. And if the lender breaks that rule, every dollar charged above the principal disappears. The borrower owes only what they borrowed.
Enforcing all of this is Consumer Protection BC. It is not a police force. It is a regulatory authority out of an office on Canada Way in Burnaby. It licenses payday lenders and debt collectors, sends inspectors into storefronts, and when an inspector finds something, they write a Report to the Director and an adjudicator decides whether the law was broken and what it costs.
That is the machine. Now let me show you 3 instances where Consumer Protection BC took on large companies on behalf of citizens of BC.
CHAPTER 3: FORT ST. JOHN. THE CHILD BENEFIT LOANS
Cashco Financial has a payday loan storefront in Fort St. John.
Cashco had history. In 2017, inspectors had found repayment problems at four other Cashco locations, and in November 2018 the company signed an Undertaking with the Director, which is a written promise to follow the law.
On October 8, 2019, Inspector Daniel O'Connor walked into the Fort St. John branch and pulled loan agreements from April through July of that year.
The borrowers were, in the company's own records, living on the Canada Child Benefit. The CCB is paid once a month, around the 20th. And these borrowers were taking a new loan every month. April 18. May 17. June 20. July 19. Each one landing on benefit day. Third loan, fourth loan, fifth loan in a row.
Under the Regulation, a third-or-subsequent loan to someone paid monthly cannot come due until after their second cheque arrives. Here is what O'Connor found. A loan advanced April 18, final payment June 17. The borrower's second benefit cheque was June 20. 3 days short. A loan advanced May 17, final payment July 18. Cheque July 19. 1 day short. June 20 loan, final payment August 19. Cheque August 20. 1 day short.
Over and over. 1 to 3 days before the money landed. 26 loans in all.
Cashco's written response conceded it: "These loans are offside." The company said it had fixed its software so a loan could not be written if the repayment dates fell outside the rules, and retrained all BC staff.
Adjudicator Robert Penkala, in June 2020, agreed. He found the loans were uniformly 1 to 3 days short. He also noted something interesting: the borrowers were generally paying these loans off early, before the second due date, so they could take the next one. The money never sat still.
The outcome was a Compliance Order: $600 in inspection costs, refund every fee charged on the affected loans, and fix the systems and report back.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: Look at who the borrowers were. Parents on the child benefit, borrowing on the day the cheque arrived and paying it straight back out. The law calls that a third-or-subsequent loan. I would call it a family living 30 days behind, permanently. The rule Cashco broke was the one rule written to interrupt that cycle. The company said the breach was 1 to 3 days. Legally, true. But those 1 to 3 days were the whole point of the rule.
CHAPTER 4: THE LIFT LOAN
The Lift Loan, created by another Cashco operation, known as Venue Financial Centres, with 8 licensed branches from Penticton to Port Alberni to Prince George. Like the previous Cashco instance mentioned earlier, they had history. In August 2016 this entity had signed its own Undertaking. It cited two specific problems: issuing new loans to borrowers who already had one, and failing to keep receipts. Remember those two.
On June 27, 2023, Inspector Mike Snyder visited the Prince George branch. The manager told him, without any apparent concern, that besides payday loans the company offered a "Flex Classic Loan," or "Lift Loan." $1,500 or less. 1-month term. Offered only in December, repaid in January. Marketed to borrowers on government social assistance.
Snyder went straight to the definition. $1,500 or less. Under 62 days. Pre-authorized debit. It was a payday loan. The company just had not called it one, and had not followed a single payday loan rule when writing it.
He asked for every Lift Loan written at all 8 branches in December 2022, plus each borrower's full loan history. It took the company 4 months to produce it.
Between December 13 and 28, 2022, the company wrote 391 Lift Loans. Every contract said the term was "1 month." Snyder did the math. December 13 to January 20 is 38 days. "1 month" is not a term, it is an approximation. None of the contracts said "high-cost." None stated the borrower's remedies. None had the mandatory paragraph about provincial regulation.
Then he cross-referenced. 11 of those 391 borrowers held a Lift Loan and a regular payday loan from the same company at the same time. In Kelowna, 4 borrowers all took Lift Loans on December 21 and all took new payday loans on January 27, a full week before the Lift Loans were paid off.
Then came the receipts. Snyder asked for the receipts given to those 11 borrowers for every payment. The company sent printouts titled "Loan Details & Payment History," every one dated September 6, 2023, the day before they were emailed. Not receipts. Records generated after the fact. He asked again. And again. On October 16, 2023, the company's compliance contact wrote back: "Our team has looked into our access of the actual receipts sent to clients and we are unable to reproduce them."
33 loans. Not one original receipt.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: Snyder asked for those receipts three separate times, in writing, and got the company to say in writing that it could not produce them. You do not have to prove a negative when the subject admits it for you. And notice the 2016 Undertaking. This company had signed a promise 7 years earlier about these exact 2 problems: overlapping loans and missing receipts. Same company, same issues, second time around.
Cashco's response was candid. On the Lift Loan, it said it had set the rate at 29.99% believing that kept it outside payday rules entirely. "I know that ignorance does not absolve us of the responsibility to remain compliant," the company wrote, "but this was in no way a direct action by Cashco attempting to deceive our clients." On the overlapping loans, it admitted them outright. On receipts, it said it had never considered a receipt part of the loan file.
Adjudicator Tegan Scardillo decided the case in April 2024. The allegation that the company committed a "deceptive act" was dismissed, on a technicality worth understanding: the inspector pleaded that the company failed to say the loan was a "payday loan," and the law does not actually require those words. It requires "high-cost loan." The contracts lacked that too, but that was not how the allegation was framed. The adjudicator ruled only on what was pleaded.
The overlapping loans and the receipts were confirmed. The company's belief that the Lift Loan was a separate product was, in her words, not a defence.
Penalty: $8,500. Plus $1,000 toward inspection costs, and an order to refund all 11 borrowers every dollar they paid above the principal, within 30 days.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: Listeners will have two reactions and both are fair. One: $8,500 for a company with 8 branches that wrote 391 non-compliant contracts in 2 weeks isn’t very much. Two: the system worked, because an inspector walked into one branch, pulled a thread, and 11 people on social assistance got their fees back. What I keep coming back to is this. Everything in this file was decided by a definition. $1,500. 62 days. Pre-authorized debit. The company designed a product it believed sat outside the rules, and the inspector held it up against a statute and it fit. Once it fit, every obligation attached automatically. Good faith did not matter. That is how administrative enforcement works. It is not about proving someone is a bad person. It is about proving a document said one thing when the law required another.
CHAPTER 5: THE OTHER END OF THE LOAN. TOLEDO CREDIT
Now I want to take you to the part of this industry that does not happen in a storefront. It happens on your phone, after you have stopped paying.
Toledo Credit is an online lender in Surrey. It makes loans and collects on them itself, which under the BPCPA makes it a "collector," bound by the same rules as a collection agency. Those rules are simple. You cannot harass a debtor. You cannot supply false or misleading information while collecting.
Consumer Protection BC started getting complaints in 2025. On July 15 of that year, Toledo told the inspector in writing that it did not report to credit bureaus, did not keep any blacklist, and only ever called someone a "fraudster" when there was documented evidence like forged ID. "A mere inability to pay," the company wrote, "is never characterized as fraud."
Hold onto that letter. It becomes the measuring stick for everything that follows.
Six complaints landed at Consumer Protection BC. The decision identifies the borrowers by initials. The company's own transcripts ran to hundreds of pages. I will describe three of the complaints.
KH. Between November 5 and December 10, 2025, Toledo hit KH by text and email, often several times a day. On November 5 alone, 14 messages. They said a "multi-jurisdictional enforcement protocol" had been activated. That KH's file would go to the RCMP, CRA and provincial crime units. That KH's character references were being contacted. That the employer would be contacted to set up wage garnishment. That a bailiff would attend KH's home or workplace "WITHIN THE NEXT 24 HOURS." One text read, simply: "Brace yourself - you were warned."
RB. November 24, 2025, 10:15 am, a text: pay today or "I will start calling your employer." RB replied that they would be contacting Consumer Protection BC. 9 minutes later, at 10:58 am, Toledo wrote: "Okay, we will file a police report as well for possible fraud since you are trying to defraud Toledo Credit by taking the funds and not paying it. Correct?" Then: "Shall we proceed with legal action?" The next day: "The choice is yours. Let's fix this in legal." And then a message stating that not paying a loan can be flagged as fraud, that Toledo was "required to report it," and that a fraud mark "can hurt your credit for up to 10 years."
After RB complained, Toledo offered $500 to settle, on one condition: RB withdraw the complaint to the regulator "in full and without reservation" and provide proof. Toledo even supplied a pre-written withdrawal letter. The offer came 1 day after the company learned the regulator was proceeding with a formal Report.
EH. This is the file that made the news. November 5, 2025, 9:24 pm: EH's account had been escalated for "immediate civil litigation and criminal referral due to confirmed pattern of chronic payment deception." The file was assigned designations, in capitals: "CHRONIC PAYMENT DECEPTION." "WILLFUL & WANTON BREACH OF CONTRACT." "FRAUDULENT CONCEALMENT OF INSOLVENCY." The next day: "permanent blacklisting across 171+ lender network." November 10: an email promising "FINANCIAL EXILE," "LEGAL ANNIHILATION" and "REPUTATIONAL DESTRUCTION," including a criminal referral to the "RCMP Financial Crimes Unit" and placement in a national fraud registry. November 12 brought the text I read you at the top of this episode. 2 minutes later, an email declaring EH a "National Financial Risk," permanently barred from regulated financial services. December 12: pay by 3:00 pm or be reported as a "FRAUDSTER." January 13, 2026: skip tracing, employer contact, and a credit file update to reflect "Intentional Payment Obstruction."
Here is the detail that got me. Throughout all of this, EH was replying. Disputing the balance. Explaining their situation. Asking for records. Asking it to stop. Toledo's messages kept claiming EH had gone silent. The record showed otherwise.
The other three files were variations on the same script. One borrower was told their missed payments "may fall under section 380 of the Criminal Code as fraud under $5,000, punishable by up to 2 years in prison," and then had their personal references phoned and texted on a Sunday evening. Another, over four months, was told: "This is not a negotiation. It's a final warning." Another got an email headed "Preliminary Lien Notice: LEGAL Alert Status" over a $411 balance.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: I spent years explaining to people what fraud actually is. Fraud requires deceit. It requires that someone obtained property by lying. Taking a loan and then being unable to pay it back is not fraud. It is a debt. A civil matter. No RCMP detachment in this country opens a file because somebody missed a payment to an online lender. The CRA does not get involved. There is no national fraud registry a private lender can put you in. And nobody can garnish your wages without going to court and getting a judgment, which takes months and lawyers. Every one of those messages was built to make a scared person believe the police, the tax man and the courts were already on their way. And the most telling thing in the whole file is RB. RB says, I am going to the regulator. 9 minutes later the collector accuses RB of fraud and threatens a police report. That is not a collection strategy. That is retaliation for asking for help.
Toledo's defence was that none of this was authorized. It said it never instructed staff to harass anyone. Without admitting any breach, it allowed that some messages "may have fallen short of its expected tone" or been perceived as "overly assertive." It said it had hired a collections manager, rewritten its templates, and now required management sign-off before any mention of fraud, police or garnishment. It asked for no monetary penalty.
Adjudicator Shahid Noorani ruled on September 24, 2026. He noted Toledo had described its fixes but provided no evidence of them. No templates, no training records, nothing.
He was careful with the law. He dismissed the allegation that the settlements obstructed the inspection, because the regulator already had the complaints and finished the job anyway, though he called the withdrawal clause "concerning." He also dismissed claims that late-night texts broke the rule against calling after 9:00 pm, ruling a text is a written communication, not a phone call.
But on harassment and false information, Toledo lost in every single file.
His reasoning drew a clean line. A creditor is allowed to say it may sue, or may go to police. What it cannot do is say a process is already activated, scheduled or imminent when it is not. Toledo claimed protocols were activated, bailiffs were scheduled, references were being contacted. It could not produce a record showing any of it was real. And the company's own July 2025 letter, saying inability to pay is never treated as fraud, directly contradicted what its collectors were telling borrowers.
Penalty: $34,000, concentrated on the KH and EH files, plus $3,000 in costs, and a Compliance Order requiring Toledo to rebuild its collection practices within 90 days and have a company officer swear under oath that it was done.
CHAPTER 6: THE SCALE OF IT
These 3 files involved a few dozen borrowers. I want to give you a sense of how small that is.
In September 2025, Consumer Protection BC announced that Cash Money, a payday chain with branches across BC, had agreed to refund $547,000 to roughly 2,800 customers. The problem was the same one from Fort St. John: contracts demanding payment before the borrower's income arrived. More than 5,600 non-compliant loans in 2 years. The regulator said it was inspecting other lenders for the same thing.
And in November 2025, the same regulator finished a file on Scotiabank. Not a payday lender. One of the biggest banks in the country. A Vancouver man in a dispute over a debt had told the bank in writing to contact him only through his lawyer. The bank allegedly called him more than 100 times in 90 days anyway. Scotiabank paid $33,900 into a consumer education fund plus $3,500 in costs, and agreed to retrain its staff.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: I include the bank for a reason. The collection rules in this province apply to everyone. A storefront in Prince George, a text-message operation in Surrey, and a chartered bank on Burrard Street are held to the same standard, and in the same 12 months all 3 fell short of it. When a bank with a compliance department the size of a small town makes 100 calls to a man who asked, in writing, to deal through his lawyer, the problem is not confined to the bottom of the market. The incentive to push is universal. The only thing that stops it is a regulator that can make pushing expensive. $33,900 is not expensive for Scotiabank. $34,000 is probably not expensive for Toledo. $8,500 was certainly not expensive for Cashco. The inspectors did careful, patient work on every one of these files..
CHAPTER 7: THE HARM
So where is the harm, if the product meets a real need? It is in three places.
The cycle. A payday loan is designed to be repaid in full on the next payday, which leaves the borrower short again that same day. So they borrow again. The Fort St. John file is the clearest picture of this I have ever seen in a government document. The same families, borrowing on on the day the child benefit landed, and paying it straight back out.
The disclosure gap. The law requires the contract to say "high-cost." It requires the contract to say where to complain. 391 Lift Loan borrowers, all on social assistance, got neither. You cannot exercise a right you do not know you have.
The collection. Blair Mantin, an insolvency trustee in BC, told the CBC that Toledo's messages did not surprise him, because he sees this every day. The worst collectors, he said, come from the lenders you only borrow from once. They know you are not coming back, so they will do anything to recover what they can. He said a significant share of the people he helps have had thoughts of ending their lives over their debt, and he believes aggressive collection pushes some of them there.
That is one trustee's observation, not a study. But I have no trouble believing it. I have stood in kitchens where the bills were stacked on the counter and the phone would not stop ringing. Fear is a tool. Toledo's collectors knew it.
Mantin also gave the single most useful advice in any of these documents. A collector has the right to call you. You have the right to hang up. You can say: I do not do business over the phone. If you want to talk about this debt, send me a letter. In BC, you can require a collector to deal with you in writing only, and the law obliges them to comply. If they do not, the regulator wants to hear about it, because, in their own words, that means the collector is breaking the law.
CHAPTER 8: WHAT EVERY BORROWER SHOULD KNOW
I want to spend a few minutes on the practical side, because almost everything in this episode happened to people who did not know the rules. The lenders knew them. The borrowers did not. So here is the short version, straight from the legislation these companies were found to have broken.
If you take a payday loan in BC, the lender must:
- Be licensed by Consumer Protection BC. If they are not, walk out.
- Charge no more than $14 for every $100 you borrow. That is the total. Interest, fees, everything.
- Give you a written contract that states the exact term of the loan in days, not "1 month," says in plain words that it is a high-cost loan, tells you what your remedies are, and includes a paragraph saying payday lending is regulated by the Province, with the regulator's contact information. If any of that is missing, the contract is not compliant.
- Lend you only 1 payday loan at a time. If you already have one with that company, they cannot write you a second, no matter what they call it.
- Never roll a loan over into a new one.
- Hand you a receipt immediately every time you make a payment, and keep every document for 2 years.
If this is your third loan with the same lender in 62 days, the rules change in your favour. The lender has to spread your repayment over at least 2 pay periods, or 3 if you are paid bi-weekly or more often, and no single instalment can be more than 35% or 50% of what you owe. If they break that rule, the law says every dollar above the principal stops being collectible. You owe what you borrowed and nothing else. That is exactly what the Fort St. John and Cash Money borrowers were refunded.
If a collector contacts you, whether it is a payday lender, an online lender, an agency, or a bank:
- They cannot harass you. Not by volume, not by tone, not by threats.
- They cannot tell you anything false or misleading. No fake police files, no fake fraud designations, no fake garnishment, no fake bailiffs.
- They cannot phone you or show up before 7:00 am or after 9:00 pm, or outside 1:00 pm to 5:00 pm on a Sunday.
- They must send you written notice before they start collecting.
- And here is the one to remember. You can tell them, in writing, to communicate with you in writing only. Once you do that, the phone calls have to stop. If they do not stop, the collector is breaking the law, and the regulator has said plainly that it wants to hear about it.
Who to call. Consumer Protection BC. Their toll-free number is 1-888-564-9963. In the Lower Mainland, 604-320-1667. Their email is info@consumerprotectionbc.ca, and their website is consumerprotectionbc.ca, where you can file a complaint online and check whether a lender is actually licensed. Keep every text and email. Screenshot them. Every finding in the Toledo decision came from the company's own messages, saved by the people who received them.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: When I was on the job, the people who got hurt worst by collectors were almost never the ones who knew their rights. They were the ones who assumed that because someone sounded official, they were. A text that says "RCMP" in capital letters is not the RCMP. The RCMP does not text. If you are ever unsure whether a threat is real, call the regulator before you pay a cent. It costs nothing, and in my experience, the moment a borrower says "I have spoken to Consumer Protection BC," the tone on the other end of the line changes completely.
EPILOGUE
3 files. A lender in Fort St. John that cut its borrowers' repayment window 1 to 3 days short, every month, on child benefit day. A lender across 8 Interior towns that built a Christmas loan for people on welfare and did not check whether the law had a name for it. An online lender in Surrey whose collectors told people the RCMP was coming.
Nobody was charged criminally. Nobody saw a courtroom. The penalties, added together, come to less than $50,000.
And yet. 122,901 British Columbians took out a payday loan last year. $364 million. The people in these files are a rounding error inside that number, and the only reason we know their stories is that 3 inspectors pulled the records and 3 adjudicators wrote it down.
If you take 1 thing from this episode, take this. If you ever get a message like the ones Toledo sent, read it twice and ask 1 question: is this telling me something that has happened, or something designed to make me afraid? The police do not text you about a loan. The CRA does not text you about a loan. Nobody can take your wages without a judge. And a lender that tells you otherwise has just handed you the evidence you need to file a complaint.
For the first responders listening, and for anyone who loves one, thank you for what you do. The calls in this episode are not the ones that make the news. They are the ones where the money ran out and somebody has been crying in the kitchen for 3 days. You go to those too. I know, because I did.
This episode was written, researched and produced by me, Ryan Dell. If this is your first time listening, and you like what you heard, please take a moment to give me a 5-star review. It helps the podcast grow and helps other people find these stories.
I love hearing from you. If you have a story I should cover, please send me an email. My email is canadiancrimecast@gmail.com.
I'm Ryan Dell, and this is Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime.
Sources: Consumer Protection BC, Report to the Director and Decision of the Director, Cashco Financial Inc. (File 30309, February 19 and June 12, 2020); Consumer Protection BC, Report to the Director and Decision of the Director, Cashco Venue Inc. dba Venue Financial Centres (File 31740, February 22 and April 10, 2024); Consumer Protection BC, Decision of the Director, Notice of Administrative Monetary Penalty and Compliance Order, Toledo Credit Inc. (Files 32170, 32171, 32172, 32177, 32273, 32304, September 24, 2026); CBC News, "Payday lender to refund $547K for alleged law violations" (September 15, 2025); CBC News, "Scotiabank agrees to change debt collection tactics after complaint over improper calling" (November 19, 2025); CBC News, "B.C. online lender fined $34K for harassing, misleading borrowers" (October 8, 2026); Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act, S.B.C. 2004, c. 2; Payday Loans Regulation; Criminal Code of Canada, s. 347.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Canadian True Crime
Kristi Lee