Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
I tell you the details and the story for interesting crimes from across Canada, with insights that only a retired RCMP officer can provide. Finally, a Canadian true crime podcast that is interesting on more than one level.
My podcasts are the best version of true crime, where you get the juicy details of the story, but also an understanding of what was happening in the minds of police investigators as they're working the case, and how certain pieces of evidence can solve the case. I also do my best to paint a picture of the day or life of the unsuspecting victim.
Just don't listen to a story of what happened, try and feel what it felt like for those involved.
Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
Jeffery Ewert - The Surrey Strangler - Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In April 1986, a New Westminster jury had to decide whether Jeffrey Ewert, who admitted killing 19-year-old Corrina Makiev, was legally insane. In Part 2, we break down what that question meant in Canadian law, the evidence that answered it, and the verdict.
Then we follow Kimberley Rendall’s family as they sue Ewert’s parents and fight to get their daughter out of a geriatric ward. We cover a 1989 trial where a judge threw out a signed confession, but still convicted. And we bring the story to today: the parole decisions, Ewert’s time at McGill’s Faculty of Law, his return to federal custody in October 2026, and the university’s independent admissions review.
As always, this episode lays out the record without taking a side on whether he belonged in that classroom.
Content warning: descriptions of murder, strangulation, and sexual violence.
SOURCES:
Contemporaneous reporting, 1984 to 1989: Langley Advance (May 16, 1984; April 23, 1986, reporting by Andre Ramshaw). The Leader (July 18, August 15, 1984; April 9, April 13, April 20, 1986; June 7, June 14, 1987; July 12, September 13, 1989, reporting by Robert Freeman). Vancouver Sun (July 12, August 14, 1984; April 2 to April 18, 1986, reporting by Larry Still; June 5, June 10, 1987, reporting by Phil Needham; September 6 to September 23, 1989, reporting by Larry Still and Carrie Mishima). The Province (July 15, August 14, 1984, reporting by Salim Jiwa; April 2 to April 18, 1986, reporting by Marc Edge; June 2, June 3, June 10, June 14, December 27, 1987, reporting by Joey Thompson and Brian Kieran; June 22, 1989, reporting by Bob Hendrickson; September 8, 1989, reporting by Joey Thompson).
Current reporting: CBC News, Convicted killer attending McGill law school divides students over safety, 2nd chances (October 2026). CBC News, Convicted murderer who attended McGill's faculty of law now back in custody (October 2026). CBC News, McGill law controversy exposes gaps in how universities handle students with criminal records (October 2026). CBC News, Convicted killer no longer enrolled at McGill after admission controversy (November 2026). CTV News Montreal, McGill University reviewing protocols after convicted murderer found to be studying on campus (October 2026). CTV News, Convicted murderer no longer enrolled at McGill; university to review admissions process (November 2026). CP24, McGill convicted murderer did not have fair process, his lawyer says (November 2026). Global News, McGill law students petition for convicted murderer to return to studies (October 2026). The Canadian Press via CTV News, Parole board ignored trauma of Indigenous man convicted of murder, court rules (August 2024).
www.canadiancrimecast.com
This episode contains descriptions of the murder of a 19-year-old woman, the attempted murder of a 15-year-old girl, strangulation, and sexual violence. If any of that is hard for you to hear right now, please take care of yourself and feel free to skip this one.
This is the second of 2 parts. If you haven't heard Part One, I'd recommend starting there.
INTRODUCTION
In Part One, we went back to the spring of 1984, in Surrey and Langley.
On May 8, a 19-year-old named Corrina Makiev was found in the Fraser River at the Barnston Island ferry slip. She'd been at the Sneakers Cabaret in Langley the night before. A man picked her up hitchhiking, choked her unconscious, raped her, and threw her into the river, where she drowned.
6 weeks later, a 15-year-old named Kimberley Rendall was choked unconscious on a basement sofa during a birthday sleepover, carried out to a car, and left in a ditch. She survived, with irreversible brain damage.
The man was Jeffrey George Ewert, 22. A Surrey RCMP constable connected the 2 cases through one detail, the nightclub. A long series of interviews followed. Then a friend went to police, and another friend handed over a 23-page letter from jail, with a map to Corrina's buried purse.
In April 1986, Ewert went on trial for first-degree murder. He admitted he killed Corrina. His defence was insanity. The jury heard about his violent dreams, an evil spirit, and a surge he said he couldn't stop. They heard 1 expert say he had a disease of the mind, and 3 say he was legally sane.
At 3:00 pm on Wednesday, April 16, 1986, the jury went out.
I'm your host, Ryan Dell. This is Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime.
CHAPTER ONE: THE LAW, EXPLAINED
Before we get to the verdict, I want to walk through the choices that jury actually had, because they weren't simple, and they explain a lot about how this trial was fought.
The insanity defence in 1986
In 1986, the Criminal Code said a person couldn't be convicted of a crime committed while they were insane. But insane had a specific legal meaning, and it's narrower than most people think.
It wasn't enough for Ewert to have something wrong with him. It wasn't enough to be angry, troubled, intoxicated, or to have had a terrible childhood. As Justice Lander explained it to the jury, Ewert had to show 2 things. First, that he had a disease of the mind. Second, that this disease made him incapable of appreciating what he was doing and its consequences, or incapable of knowing it was wrong.
And unlike almost everything else in a criminal trial, the burden here was on the accused. The defence had to prove it was more likely than not. The Crown didn't have to disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt.
The judge also told the jury what an insanity verdict would mean, because a lot of people assume it means walking free. It doesn't. If they found him not guilty by reason of insanity, Ewert would be sent to a mental health institution and treated, and he wouldn't be released until the authorities were satisfied it was safe. In practice, that could mean being held indefinitely.
A few years after this trial, in 1992, Parliament rewrote this part of the law and renamed it. Today it's called being not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder. But the core idea, whether the person could understand what they were doing or that it was wrong, is still at the centre of it.
The 3 levels of homicide
If the jury decided Ewert was sane, they still had to decide what he was guilty of. Canadian law has 3 main levels of culpable homicide, and Justice Lander walked them through each one as it applied here.
First-degree murder. Most people think first-degree means planned and deliberate, and that's one route. But there's another one. Under the law at the time, a murder committed while the killer is committing certain other serious crimes, including sexual assault, is automatically first-degree, planned or not. That was the Crown's theory. The judge told the jury that if Ewert killed Corrina while committing a sexual assault on her, it was first-degree murder.
Second-degree murder. If the jury found the killing was an act separate from the sexual assault, not part of it, it would be second-degree. Still murder. The person meant to kill, or meant to cause injuries they knew were likely to kill, but it doesn't fall into the first-degree category.
Manslaughter. If the jury found Ewert had consumed so much alcohol that he couldn't form the intent required for murder, the verdict would be manslaughter.
The difference in consequences was huge. Both kinds of murder carry an automatic life sentence. But first-degree means no chance at parole for 25 years. Second-degree, at that time, could mean parole eligibility after as little as 10 years. And manslaughter carried anything from a suspended sentence up to life.
Why that matters here
Think about the order of events in Ewert's own account. He choked Corrina until she was unconscious. Then he sexually assaulted her. Then, believing she was dead, he threw her in the river, where she actually died.
When exactly did the killing happen, and was it bound up with the sexual assault, or separate from it? That's exactly the kind of question the first-degree versus second-degree instruction asks a jury to work out. Hold onto that question. It comes back at the end of this story.
CHAPTER TWO: THE EVIDENCE, AND HOW THE JURY WEIGHED IT
This is the part of the episode where I lay out what the jury had in front of it and how each piece could be used. With one caveat. Canadian juries don't give reasons. Nobody outside that jury room knows exactly what persuaded them, so what follows is how the evidence lined up against the legal test, not a claim about what any juror was thinking.
Remember, identity was never in dispute. Ewert admitted the killing. So the real question was narrow: did he prove, on a balance of probabilities, that a disease of the mind left him unable to appreciate what he was doing, or unable to know it was wrong?
Here's the evidence that pointed toward insanity.
The dreams. Years of violent dreams, described in detail on the police tapes, about stabbing his father and cutting people down with a sword.
The evil spirit. A story he told Glen DesRoches after the killing, and told again on the stand, of something that came in the night and possessed him.
His description of the attacks themselves. Hands acting on their own. A surge he couldn't stop. Telling police he thought the attack on Kimberley had been a bad dream.
His background. An adoptive mother with serious mental illness, a home full of conflict, and a mother who, by his account, mocked his Indigenous heritage.
And Dr. Koopman's diagnosis of episodic discontrol, a recurring loss of control over rage.
Now here's the evidence that pointed the other way, and there was a lot more of it.
The cleanup. After choking Corrina, he didn't wander off in a daze. He drove to a remote ferry dock and put her in the river. A Crown expert told the jury the purpose was to destroy evidence. After attacking Kimberley, he changed his bloody clothes. Hours later, he came home and put the bloody pillow in the washing machine. Those are the actions of someone who knows what he's done and knows it can get him caught.
The purse. He kept it, then buried it, then drew a map to it.
The letter. 23 pages of instructions to wipe fingerprints, fake notes, plant shoes, burn the shawl and nylons, and invent a phone call at Safeway. You can't plan a cover-up of a crime unless you understand it's a crime and what happens when you're caught.
The reason he gave for Kimberley. This might be the most important piece of all. By his own statement to police, he decided to kill a 15-year-old girl because he was afraid she'd lead police back to the Makiev murder. That isn't a man who can't appreciate consequences. That's a man thinking several steps ahead about consequences, and deciding a witness has to die.
His own words about control. On tape, he'd told police that when he was sober he was always in full control, and that he took out his frustrations on objects, never people.
His intelligence. His own expert said he was above average in reasoning.
The experts. 3 for the Crown, all saying legally sane. 1 for the defence.
And finally, the things he said to police after he was charged. That it was really wild. That killing the first one made the second one easier. Way to go, guys.
If I'm reading the legal test against that evidence, the defence had a very steep hill. Even if every word about the dreams and the spirit was believed, the law didn't ask whether Ewert was troubled. It asked whether he knew what he was doing and knew it was wrong. Almost everything he did after each attack suggested he knew both.
The verdict
The jury went out at 3:00 pm, spent the night at a hotel, and were back in the jury room at 10:00 am the next morning. How long they deliberated depends on which paper you read. The Province said almost 24 hours. The Vancouver Sun said about 10 hours. The Langley Advance said more than 8. The likely explanation is that one count includes the overnight break and the others only count the time they were actually in the jury room.
On Thursday, April 17, 1986, they returned.
Sane. And guilty of first-degree murder.
Justice Lander imposed the only sentence the law allowed. Life imprisonment, with no eligibility for parole for 25 years. Ewert stood without any visible reaction.
Corrina's father, Fred Makiev, clapped and gave a quiet cheer in the courtroom. Afterward, he told reporters the last 2 years had been tough, and that the waiting was the hardest part. He said the police had done a hell of a job. And he said that while he didn't think it should apply in every murder case, he was in favour of capital punishment for people who kill because they enjoy it.
Kimberley's mother, Marilyn Dorland, and her stepfather, Leo, had been sitting behind Ewert while the details of their daughter's attack were read into the record. Outside court, Marilyn said that at least now he couldn't do it to any other young girls. Leo called him a coward.
Rick Miller told reporters it wasn't over. Ewert still faced the attempted murder charge for Kimberley, and another unrelated sexual assault charge.
That second trial wouldn't happen for another 3 and a half years.
CHAPTER THREE: THE PARENTS ON TRIAL
In June of 1987, there was a third courtroom, and this time the Ewerts sitting at the defence table weren't Jeffrey. They were his parents.
Kimberley's mother, Marilyn Dorland, and her common-law husband, Leo, sued John and Marion Ewert in B.C. Supreme Court. A quick note on names. Kimberley's stepfather appears in some reports as Leo Dorland and in others as Leo D'Onofrio. It's the same man.
The family wasn't after a moral victory. They were after money to care for their daughter, who by then was 18 and living in the geriatric ward of Peace Arch Hospital in White Rock, sharing it with patients aged 75 to 105.
They'd already won a default judgment against Jeffrey himself. It was worthless. As Marilyn put it, he was in Kent Institution and didn't own a thing.
So they sued the people who owned the house.
The legal theory
The claim was brought under B.C.'s Occupiers Liability Act. In plain language, if you own or control a property, you owe the people you invite onto it a duty to take reasonable care that they'll be reasonably safe while they're there. That can include the conduct of other people on the property, if the danger is something you knew about, or should have known about.
The family's lawyer, Ian Sisett, argued exactly that. The Ewerts, he said, knew or ought to have known that their son was a walking timebomb. He'd been violent before, including toward his own mother.
The Ewerts' lawyer, Bruce Butler, answered with the basic rule. People are not ordinarily held responsible for the criminal acts of someone else unless they failed to take steps against something that was reasonably foreseeable. And he asked the jury to be careful about hindsight. They were hearing things in that courtroom, he said, that his clients didn't know at the time.
Justice Kenneth Meredith decided the jury, 6 women and 2 men, would deal with liability first. Only if they found the Ewerts liable would they go on to hear about damages.
What the jury heard
They watched a video of Kimberley in her hospital bed, unable to walk, talk or swallow, fed through a tube in her stomach. Her stepfather told them about the girl who learned to moonwalk and ate hamburgers by the platter. He told them that when doctors said she'd never improve, his answer was "bull." He'd played her music, kept at her, pushed her, and now she was making sounds and kicking her legs.
Dr. Peter Robin testified there were no adequate facilities in B.C. for young people as badly injured as Kimberley. Dr. George Hahn, from the G.F. Strong Rehabilitation Centre, said a geriatric ward was no place for her. The only possibility on the horizon was a proposed ward for young adults at Vancouver's Pearson Hospital, which wasn't operating yet and depended on funding from the Ministry of Health.
Then Marion Ewert took the stand. She was 51. She'd wanted a dozen children, she said, but stopped at 4. All were adopted, because she couldn't have children herself. Jeffrey came to them at 4 months old. She said the Children's Aid Society told her his birth mother was part Cree and his birth father was a drummer in a band at Buckingham Palace.
She said that until he was 14, Jeffrey was a fun-loving kid with no discipline problems at school. She described her own diagnosis of manic depression in the early 1970s, and 6 hospital stays for depression. From the time Jeffrey was 14, she said, they argued constantly, and she got him in to see the same counsellor she was seeing at Surrey Mental Health.
At 16, he went to live with relatives near Pemberton for 2 years. When he came back, the arguments started again, and he often slapped her. He gave her a black eye once. She testified he pushed her against walls and sometimes across a room, and once dumped compost on her head. She said her husband drank too much, spent a lot of time at the Legion, and didn't protect her, and that Jeffrey had 2 faces.
But she also told the jury Jeffrey had stopped being abusive toward her about 6 months before the attack on Kimberley. He'd been living away from home. Her children's friends stayed over all the time without any trouble. She said she had no reason to believe Kimberley wouldn't be safe in her house.
John Ewert's statement to police painted a similar picture. A pleasant child who did well in school, who changed as a teenager, became excitable, with a bad temper, constantly fighting with his mother. A couple of times, John said, he'd had to physically restrain Jeffrey and throw him out of the house.
The verdict
On June 9, 1987, the jury was asked a single question. Should John and Marion Ewert have reasonably foreseen that Kimberley might be harmed in their home?
After an hour and a half, they answered no.
That ended the case against the parents. Their lawyer withdrew, the jury was discharged, and the question of how much Jeffrey owed was left to the judge alone, knowing that whatever number he picked would never be paid.
That night, Marilyn Dorland told The Province the family was deep in debt but would keep fighting. They wanted to appeal, but didn't have the $15,000 it would cost.
They found a way. On June 21, 1989, the B.C. Court of Appeal ruled, 2 to 1, that the jury got it right. Justice William Esson, writing for the majority, didn't paint a flattering picture of the Ewert home. He described it as squalid, a place where drugs and alcohol were tolerated. But the parents couldn't reasonably be expected to know that Jeffrey, who had his own apartment, would be a danger to a guest. The family said they were considering taking it to the Supreme Court of Canada. The clippings don't tell us whether they did.
CHAPTER FOUR: KIM
I want to step out of the courtrooms for a minute, because the trials tell you what happened to Kimberley Rendall on one night. They don't tell you what happened to her after.
She was in a coma for at least a year. She was moved from Royal Columbian Hospital to the extended care unit at Peace Arch Hospital in White Rock, where the rest of the patients were elderly. Her mother said the first time she saw her daughter after the attack, she couldn't recognize her. Somebody told her Kim might have been better off if she'd died.
Her parents didn't accept that.
They went to the hospital twice a day, every day. On top of whatever the hospital provided, they spent about 5 hours a day doing their own therapy with her, talking to her, holding her hand, playing her music, trying to keep her stimulated. Doctors told them to keep trying to communicate, and they did. Leo said you get out of it what you put into it. Marilyn said you never give up.
Slowly, things changed. Kim came off the machine that had been helping her breathe. She began to move her head a little. She started making sounds and moving her legs.
In the summer of 1987, 5 people in White Rock read about Kimberley in the Sunday edition of The Province. A businessman named Tom Ivanore and 4 others started what they called the Kimberley Trust Fund, a pool of money for Kim and for other victims of crime.
By Christmas of that year, the fund had raised about $30,000. It bought her a new wardrobe and a new wheelchair, and paid for a month of rehabilitation at a school in Victoria where trained therapists worked with her. A private nurse started helping her get ready in the mornings.
Because Kimberley was going to school.
She was attending classes at Frank Hurt Secondary in Surrey. She was learning to swim. She was learning to communicate electronically, turning her head to trigger buttons. Ever since the attack she'd refused food and had to be fed through a tube. Now she was eating Big Macs and pizza.
The week before Christmas 1987, her family threw her a party they called her new beginning. Her mother said it was their happiest Christmas in 4 years. Kim turned 19 on December 28. Her stepfather said they were determined she was going to walk again.
By September of 1989, the fund had raised somewhere between $45,000 and $50,000. It had sent Kim to camp.
But there were limits to what love and money could do. In 1989, Marilyn said her daughter still couldn't walk or speak. She said Kim understood everything that was happening around her but couldn't respond, and that she cried a lot out of frustration. She knew she was in a hospital with old people. She wanted desperately to come home. Kim remembered nothing of the attack. Her mother told her she'd had an accident.
The Crown, at sentencing in 1989, described her condition in much starker medical terms. A quadriplegic. Blind. Spastic. Profoundly cognitively disabled. Those 2 descriptions, a mother's and a prosecutor's, don't fully line up, and I'm not going to pretend I can reconcile them from newspaper clippings. What they agree on is that the life Kimberley Rendall was supposed to have was gone.
The newspaper record I have ends in 1989. I don't know where Kimberley's life went from there, and I'm not going to guess.
CHAPTER FIVE: THE SECOND TRIAL
You might be wondering why Ewert wasn't tried for Kimberley at the same time as Corrina. The answer is a rule of criminal procedure. At the time, when someone was charged with murder, other unrelated offences couldn't be included in the same indictment. So the Rendall charge was set aside until the murder case was done.
You might also wonder why the Crown bothered at all. Ewert was already serving life. Any sentence for attempted murder would have to run at the same time, so it couldn't add a single day. Rick Miller answered that outside court. The Crown felt there should be public condemnation of what Ewert did to Kimberley, even if he was beyond any additional punishment.
The trial began on Tuesday, September 5, 1989, in B.C. Supreme Court in New Westminster. Ewert, now 27, chose to be tried by a judge alone. Justice Allan Stewart presided. Rick Miller prosecuted again. Ewert had a new lawyer, Michael Tammen. Ewert wore leg shackles in the courtroom. One paper noted he'd tried to escape custody in the past.
And Ewert pleaded not guilty.
That might surprise you. He'd already admitted the Rendall attack at his 1986 trial. But those admissions were part of a defence strategy in a different case. Here, the Crown had to prove the attempted murder all over again, with admissible evidence, and Tammen's job was to make them do exactly that. As he put it afterward, everyone is entitled to the presumption of innocence, and the defence's job is to make sure the Crown proves its case.
The mirror image
There was a neat symmetry in how the Crown built this one. In 1986, it used the Rendall attack to help prove the Makiev murder. In 1989, it reversed that. Now it wanted to use the Makiev murder to prove the Rendall attack.
Why? Because of motive. The Crown's theory was the one Ewert gave police himself. He tried to kill Kimberley to stop her from leading police to Corrina. You can't prove that motive without telling the judge about Corrina.
Tammen objected. Evidence that an accused committed a different crime is normally kept out, because the risk is that the court thinks, he's a bad man, so he probably did this too. Tammen argued that prejudice far outweighed any value as evidence.
The trial within a trial
Most of this trial was spent on something called a voir dire, which is basically a trial within a trial. The judge hears the disputed evidence first, along with how it was obtained, and then decides whether it can be used at all.
The disputed evidence was Ewert's confessions. Tammen argued police had broken the rules in 3 ways. They'd offered him inducements, especially psychiatric help, to get him to talk. They'd offered him immunity for other offences. And they'd discouraged him from talking to a lawyer before he gave a statement, which violated his rights under the Charter.
So the officers took the stand again, and this time the focus was entirely on how they did it.
Constable Greg Johnson confirmed the note ruse, the false claim that Kimberley had woken up and identified her attacker. He agreed police offered Ewert immunity from prosecution for other offences he might have committed. He agreed Ewert was questioned many times over about 2 months, with a nice-guy team alternating with a hard-nosed team. And he agreed that, after all those interviews, police had no physical evidence linking Ewert to the attack on Kimberley.
Tammen suggested police set out to get a confession and went at it pretty vigorously. Johnson said that in any case he investigates, he always wants a confession.
Then came the detail that would matter most. Johnson agreed that police tape-recorded the interviews where Ewert said nothing incriminating. But the interview where Ewert actually confessed, on September 17, 1984, was not recorded. Johnson said he removed the recorder because he thought it might inhibit Ewert.
Johnson also testified that during that interview, Ewert was cocky, arrogant and sarcastic, and seemed to enjoy describing what he'd done. When Tammen pointed out that none of that was in his notes, Johnson said he didn't need to write it down because he'd never forget Ewert's attitude. Tammen suggested he'd made it up for effect. Johnson said absolutely not.
Ewert got so angry at Johnson's testimony that he asked the judge if he could be taken out of the courtroom. He called Johnson a liar as he was led out.
Corporal James Moore testified next. He admitted again that he lied about the psychology degree and about being abused as a child, and that both teams had discussed Ewert's weak spots and tender spots before Moore went in.
The apology letter Ewert wrote to Kimberley in July 1984 was entered as an exhibit. When it was read aloud, Ewert broke down and cried in court.
Kimberley's mother was in that courtroom for much of it, reading along with the transcripts while the tapes played. She told a reporter afterward that a couple of times she couldn't stand it and had to walk out.
The orchestra
When the lawyers made their arguments, Justice Stewart put his finger on the problem with a musical image. Police had introduced the theme of psychiatric help gently, early on, over 2 months of interviews. Only the horn section was playing, he said, not the full orchestra. But he said inducements like that could make the confession inadmissible.
Miller replied in kind. The theme might be there, he said, but it isn't what's causing him to dance, and it isn't what's causing him to sing. Ewert didn't talk when police lied to him, tricked him, or told him things were off the record. In the Crown's view, Ewert talked when he wanted to, because he was proud of what he'd done and wanted to talk about it.
On the right to counsel, Miller said Ewert had been given his Charter rights when he was arrested, and police weren't required to repeat that warning before every single interview.
The ruling
On Thursday, September 14, 1989, Justice Stewart did something nobody expected.
He threw out Ewert's signed confession.
He was careful to say he didn't think Constables Johnson and Perka had tried to deceive the court. But there were gaps in their evidence about the circumstances in which the signed statement was given. And for a confession to be admitted, the Crown has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that it was voluntary. With those gaps, he couldn't be satisfied of that.
He also excluded every statement Ewert made in the interviews where he'd been offered psychiatric help in exchange for confessing.
But he admitted the unsigned verbal statement from September 17, 1984, the one recorded only in the notes Johnson and Moore wrote after the interview. He found the earlier inducements didn't taint that one.
That statement contained the core of the Crown's case. Ewert's account of choking Corrina because she rebuffed him. His hands acting independently. His description of it as the perfect crime, because no one was there to see. And his explanation for Kimberley: the fear in her eyes, the worry that she'd tell, and the decision to kill her so the police wouldn't find out about Corrina.
The Crown also produced a surprise witness, a former inmate at the Oakalla prison who said Ewert described the Rendall attack to him in 1986. His name was covered by a publication ban. Justice Stewart had doubts about him from the start, and found his credibility destroyed on cross-examination. The judge rejected his evidence completely.
The verdict
On Friday, September 15, 1989, Justice Stewart found Ewert guilty of attempted murder. He said he was satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that when Ewert attacked Kimberley, he had a firm and specific intention to kill her. Ewert's own explanation to police showed his purpose was to eliminate a potential witness.
Marilyn Dorland said she was relieved it was attempted murder and not just aggravated assault. But she was angry that it wouldn't add a day to his sentence. She said he might get out after 25 years, but her daughter never would.
The sentence
On September 22, 1989, Ewert stood in the prisoner's box in leg shackles, a gold cross hanging from his left ear, and showed no emotion.
Justice Stewart sentenced him to life in prison, to be served at the same time as his life sentence for murder. He'd commended Tammen for providing an excellent defence. Then he spoke directly to Ewert, and the reporter in the room described his tone as icy.
He called Ewert cold and callous, a hollow man unable to recognize that other people have rights, including the right to live. He said Ewert was a certain and unremitting danger to the community. He described him as a psychopath, someone who hides behind what the judge called a mask of sanity. He told Ewert he had been motivated by a desire to save his own skin by taking the life of another human being.
And he said, in effect, that in his view Ewert should never be released.
The Crown filed a victim impact statement from Marilyn Dorland. 9 handwritten pages. She wrote that she was a totally different person now. She couldn't say whether her anger or her grief was greater. She kept asking herself why, and never got an answer. She kept no pictures of Kim in her house, because she couldn't look at her the way she used to be. She couldn't sleep. No matter what time she went to bed, she was up at 5:30 or 6:00 am. She described her daughter as a mind trapped inside a body that no longer worked, for the rest of her life. And she wrote that she would never see Kim grow up, get married, have a family, or have a career.
Rick Miller told the judge the impact on Kimberley and her family was at least equal to a completed murder.
Outside court, Miller gave the credit to Johnson and Moore for what he called superb police work. He went back through it for reporters. When Corrina was found, police had few clues and Ewert wasn't a suspect. When Kimberley was attacked, he came under suspicion because of where it happened. Johnson wasn't satisfied with Ewert's story about being at Sneakers, noticed that Corrina had been at the same club, and found a patron who remembered them talking. With nothing more than that connection, a series of intense interrogations over about 3 months produced confessions to both.
Under the law, Ewert's earliest parole eligibility date was 2011. The judge noted the attempted murder conviction would be a factor in any application he made.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: I want to talk about what held up and what didn't, because this ruling is a textbook lesson. The confession Ewert signed, the one you'd expect to be the gold standard, got thrown out. Not because anyone lied to the court, but because the officers couldn't fill in every detail of how it was taken. What survived was the notes of 2 officers written after an interview that wasn't even recorded. Think about that. Police taped the interviews where nothing happened, and turned the recorder off for the one that mattered most. In 1984 that was a judgment call meant to get a suspect talking. Today, recording that interview would be expected, and an unrecorded confession would face a much harder road. The other lesson is about inducements. The lies, the fake note, the photograph, the insults, none of those sank the statement. What sank part of this case was the repeated suggestion that confessing would get him help. When you offer someone something in exchange for talking, you hand the defence the argument that he only said it to get the reward. And finally, I'll say again what Rick Miller said. Everything in this file traces back to one constable who heard the word Sneakers twice and didn't let it go.
CHAPTER SIX: FORTY YEARS LATER
The newspaper clippings I've been working from stop in the fall of 1989. The last thing they tell us is that Ewert had an appeal of his murder conviction coming up, scheduled for October 17 of that year.
And here's something you'll notice if you read the current coverage. The 1986 jury convicted Ewert of first-degree murder. Today's reporting, from CBC, CTV and The Canadian Press, describes his convictions as second-degree murder and attempted murder. Remember the question from Chapter One of this episode, about whether the killing was part of the sexual assault or separate from it? It's possible that's where this went. But the record in front of me doesn't show when, how, or why the conviction changed, so I'm not going to fill that gap with a guess.
What we do know is that Ewert spent about 4 decades in federal custody.
Who he is
In 1986, Ewert told the jury he was one-quarter Cree. Current reporting describes his birth mother as Métis. And some of his supporters at McGill have described him as a survivor of the Sixties Scoop.
A quick explainer on that term. The Sixties Scoop refers to a period, starting in the 1960s and running for decades, when child welfare authorities in Canada removed large numbers of Indigenous children from their families and communities and placed them for adoption, most often with non-Indigenous families. You'll remember from Part One that Ewert was adopted at 4 months old, in the early 1960s, and that he told police his adoptive mother mocked his Indigenous background.
In prison, Ewert began following Indigenous spiritual teachings. Reporting on his parole says he took part in a healing process grounded in traditional teachings, which he credits with helping him manage his anger, his triggers, and his substance use.
The road to parole
In December 2022, the Parole Board of Canada turned down his first application for day parole, concluding he still posed an undue risk to society. His correctional file, as reported by The Canadian Press, found he had a need to dominate and control women, problems managing his emotions, an explosive temperament, and a distrust of others.
Ewert challenged that decision. In July 2024, a Federal Court judge overturned it, finding the board hadn't properly considered what are called Gladue factors.
Gladue comes from a 1999 Supreme Court of Canada decision. It requires courts, and later parole decision-makers, to consider the particular circumstances of Indigenous people, including the effects of colonialism, residential schools, and systemic racism. In Ewert's case, the Federal Court found the board hadn't given enough weight to his traumatic childhood or the healing work he'd done. The case went back to the board for a new assessment. At that point he was being held in Laval, Quebec, and had asked for day parole to a Salvation Army halfway house in Saskatoon.
In February 2025, Ewert was granted day parole.
Three months later, in May 2025, it was temporarily suspended. According to the parole board's decisions, as reported by CBC, he had contacted several women and collected their phone numbers, and a counsellor at the facility where he was living had concerns about his attitude and behaviour. The board also noted that Ewert continued to maintain that his interactions with women weren't a risk factor, and that he denied there was a sexual element to his crimes, despite what the court records say.
He was released again. In June 2026, his day parole was extended for another 6 months. Clinical assessments rated his risk of reoffending as moderate to high. Parole documents said that with close supervision at a halfway house and clinical follow-up, that risk appeared to fall closer to moderate. The board again expressed concern about his interactions with women and his attitudes toward them.
McGill
In August 2026, Ewert started attending classes and faculty events at McGill's Faculty of Law in Montreal, returning to a halfway house at night.
In mid-October, CBC News reported who he was. Students say they hadn't seen him on campus since early October.
The reaction split the faculty.
Some students said the university had put them at risk by not telling them about his violent history, and some said they were particularly worried for female classmates. One petition laid out why some students felt unsafe and pointed to concerns about his alleged behaviour while attending McGill. More than 40 students signed an open letter asking that he be kept off campus for the rest of the academic year.
Other students and some faculty pushed back. A second petition argued that excluding Ewert undermined his access to education and rehabilitation as an Indigenous man and a survivor of the Sixties Scoop. One of the professors who signed it told CBC the solution is not to deny someone education. Another law student started a petition of his own asking McGill to let Ewert return.
Ewert's lawyer, Nora Demnati, said he'd been very honest about his history, his parole status, and his conditions. When CBC asked about some of his activity on social media, she said she didn't know the specifics, but that occasional breaches are to be expected from someone who spent nearly 4 decades in prison.
Back in custody
Then, in late October, Correctional Service Canada issued a suspension warrant for Jeffrey Ewert. According to CBC's sources, he was picked up on a Friday, and CSC confirmed it the next day. CTV reported the date as October 25. CSC said Ewert had been returned to custody while it conducted a more thorough assessment of the situation. In a general statement, CSC said that when the risk an offender poses can no longer be safely managed in the community, it can suspend their release.
In what I've read, CSC hasn't said publicly what specifically triggered the suspension, and I'm not going to speculate.
Here's how the process works from here, in plain language. A suspension isn't the same as having your parole taken away. It's a pause. CSC does a risk assessment. It can cancel the suspension and release him again, or it can refer the case to the Parole Board of Canada for what's called a post-suspension review. The board can then cancel the suspension, or revoke his parole altogether. Until that decision is made, Ewert stays in custody.
No longer enrolled
On Monday, November 2, McGill's provost, Angela Campbell, sent a memo to students. Ewert was no longer enrolled. The memo didn't say whether he withdrew or whether the university revoked his enrolment. A McGill spokesperson said provincial privacy laws prevented the university from saying more. The spokesperson also pointed out that criminal background checks aren't typically part of university admissions in Canada.
Campbell also announced an independent review of McGill's admissions processes and protocols, starting with the Faculty of Law. She said the goal was to make sure procedures are rigorous enough, that responsibilities are clearly defined, and that the process reflects the university's values and its duty of care. She also said McGill remains committed to dignity and to second chances. The review is expected to take several months.
Some students have floated their own idea: an ethics committee made up of university representatives, students, and an outside expert in risk management or rehabilitation, to oversee how any future student with a violent criminal conviction is brought into campus life. Others, including a student newspaper editorial at another university, have suggested remote learning as a middle ground.
A few days later, on November 7, Ewert's lawyer released a statement giving her side of what happened. According to Demnati, McGill revoked Ewert's admission. She said it wasn't because of student concerns, but because of an alleged failure to disclose parts of a 2025 Parole Board decision in his application. She said nothing in McGill's admissions guidance asks for that kind of information. She also said his conduct as a student didn't raise concerns at the time, and was only scrutinized afterward through the lens of his past convictions, and she questioned whether the process was fair.
McGill hasn't publicly confirmed her account.
Where it stands
As of this recording, Jeffrey Ewert is back in federal custody, waiting on a risk assessment that will decide whether he's released again or whether the Parole Board reviews his case. He's no longer a McGill student. And McGill's review of how he got there is just getting started.
A lawyer who has represented many people serving life sentences told CBC that getting parole in the first place is hard, and that authorities are always balancing 2 things: rehabilitation and community safety. That tension runs through this whole story.
Whether Jeffrey Ewert belonged in that classroom is a real question, and people on both sides have argued it in good faith. I'm not going to answer it for you. My job was to make sure that when you weigh it, you know what actually happened.
A FINAL THOUGHT
When a case like this comes back into the news, the story tends to become about the man. His parole, his education, his rights, his risk. That's understandable. He's the one in the headlines.
But I don't want to end on him.
Corrina Lea Makiev was 19 years old. 5 foot 2. Brown hair, brown eyes. She went out on a Monday night in Langley, and at 2:30 in the morning she was walking home. She got into a car because somebody offered her a ride. When he made a move, she told him no, and asked him to take her home. That's the last thing we know she said.
Her father, Fred, waited 2 years for a verdict. He said the waiting was the hardest part.
Kimberley Rendall was 15. She played clarinet. She made up dance routines with her best friend and taught herself to moonwalk. She went to a birthday party at a friend's house and fell asleep on a couch, in a place where she had every reason to feel safe. She woke up to a man's hands on her throat, and the girl she was never really woke up again.
Her mother wrote that she'd never get to see Kim grow up. Her parents sat at her bedside twice a day for years, refusing to accept what the doctors told them. And with the help of a handful of strangers in White Rock who read her story in a Sunday paper, they got her to a high school classroom.
Before I let you go, I want to say something about the people in this story who don't usually get mentioned.
The truck driver who found Corrina at the ferry slip, and the 2 kids who found Kimberley in that ditch. The paramedics and the staff at Royal Columbian who kept a 15-year-old alive when her chances were described as minimal. The nurses at Peace Arch who cared for her for years. The investigators who stood on that riverbank in May with nothing to go on, and the constable who heard the word Sneakers twice and pulled the thread.
And 2 people who weren't first responders at all. Glen DesRoches and Robert MacDonald, who had to decide whether their loyalty to a friend was worth more than justice for a young woman they'd never met. They chose her.
To every first responder listening, the ones who carry calls like these home with them and never really put them down: what you do costs something real, whether anyone sees it or not. Thank you. And if you know someone who does that work, check in on them.
Take care of each other out there.
This episode was written, researched, and produced by me, Ryan Dell. If you liked what you heard, please take a moment to give the show a 5-star review. It helps other people find these stories.
I love hearing from you. If there's a case you think I should cover, send me an email. My address is: canadiancrimecast@gmail.com.
I'm Ryan Dell, and this is Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime.
SOURCES
Contemporaneous reporting, 1984 to 1989: Langley Advance (May 16, 1984; April 23, 1986, reporting by Andre Ramshaw). The Leader (July 18, August 15, 1984; April 9, April 13, April 20, 1986; June 7, June 14, 1987; July 12, September 13, 1989, reporting by Robert Freeman). Vancouver Sun (July 12, August 14, 1984; April 2 to April 18, 1986, reporting by Larry Still; June 5, June 10, 1987, reporting by Phil Needham; September 6 to September 23, 1989, reporting by Larry Still and Carrie Mishima). The Province (July 15, August 14, 1984, reporting by Salim Jiwa; April 2 to April 18, 1986, reporting by Marc Edge; June 2, June 3, June 10, June 14, December 27, 1987, reporting by Joey Thompson and Brian Kieran; June 22, 1989, reporting by Bob Hendrickson; September 8, 1989, reporting by Joey Thompson).
Current reporting: CBC News, Convicted killer attending McGill law school divides students over safety, 2nd chances (October 2026). CBC News, Convicted murderer who attended McGill's faculty of law now back in custody (October 2026). CBC News, McGill law controversy exposes gaps in how universities handle students with criminal records (October 2026). CBC News, Convicted killer no longer enrolled at McGill after admission controversy (November 2026). CTV News Montreal, McGill University reviewing protocols after convicted murderer found to be studying on campus (October 2026). CTV News, Convicted murderer no longer enrolled at McGill; university to review admissions process (November 2026). CP24, McGill convicted murderer did not have fair process, his lawyer says (November 2026). Global News, McGill law students petition for convicted murderer to return to studies (October 2026). The Canadian Press via CTV News, Parole board ignored trauma of Indigenous man convicted of murder, court rules (August 2024).
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Canadian True Crime
Kristi Lee