Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
I tell you the details and the story for interesting crimes from across Canada, with insights that only a retired RCMP officer can provide. Finally, a Canadian true crime podcast that is interesting on more than one level.
My podcasts are the best version of true crime, where you get the juicy details of the story, but also an understanding of what was happening in the minds of police investigators as they're working the case, and how certain pieces of evidence can solve the case. I also do my best to paint a picture of the day or life of the unsuspecting victim.
Just don't listen to a story of what happened, try and feel what it felt like for those involved.
Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime
Jeffery Ewert - The Surrey Strangler - Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On May 8, 1984, Corrina Makiev, 19, was found in the Fraser River at the Barnston Island ferry slip. She’d last been seen after a night at the Sneakers Cabaret in Langley. Six weeks later, 15-year-old Kimberley Rendall was choked unconscious during a birthday sleepover in Surrey and left in a ditch.
The man behind both attacks was Jeffrey George Ewert, a 22-year-old delivery driver. Ewert has been back in the news after attending law classes at McGill University while on day parole. In Part 1, we go back to where it started: the 2 attacks, the detail that connected them, the friends who went to police, a 23-page letter from jail, and the opening of his 1986 murder trial.
Content warning: this episode includes descriptions of murder, strangulation, and sexual violence.
www.canadiancrimecast.com
This episode contains descriptions of the murder of a 19-year-old woman, the attempted murder of a 15-year-old girl, strangulation, and sexual violence. If any of that is hard for you to hear right now, please take care of yourself and feel free to skip this one.
A note on sources. Almost everything in this episode comes from newspaper coverage written at the time, between 1984 and 1989, in the Langley Advance, The Leader, the Vancouver Sun, and The Province.
It's Tuesday, May 8, 1984. Just before noon.
A truck driver who lives on Barnston Island pulls up to the ferry slip on the south side of the Fraser River, at the foot of 104 Avenue in Surrey. It's an ordinary trip. He's done it a hundred times.
This time there's something in the shallow water.
It's a young woman. 5 feet 2 inches, 114 pounds, brown hair, brown eyes. She's wearing a black and white zebra-print mini dress and a gold box-link chain.
Her name is Corrina Lea Makiev. She's 19 years old. About 9 hours earlier, at 2:30 am, somebody saw her walking near the Langley Provincial Court House. The night before that, she'd been at a cabaret in Langley called Sneakers.
Police have almost nothing to go on. A week later they put out a public appeal. Several people have been questioned. There are no suspects.
Now jump ahead 6 weeks. June 17, 1984. Two children playing near 158A Street and 112 Avenue in Surrey find a 15-year-old girl lying in a ditch, unconscious, dressed in a blue nightie. Her jaw is broken in 2 places. Her skull is fractured. A few hours earlier she'd been asleep on a sofa in the basement of a family home, at a birthday sleepover.
Two cases. Two different detachment files. On paper, nothing to tie them together.
Except one word. Sneakers.
The man who connected them was a 22-year-old delivery driver from Langley named Jeffrey George Ewert.
If that name sounds familiar right now, there's a reason. In August of this year, Ewert, now in his 60s and on day parole, started attending law classes at McGill University in Montreal. When students found out who he was, it set off a debate that played out in newspapers and on newscasts across the country. Some students said they felt unsafe and were never told. Others signed petitions asking that he be allowed to stay. By late October, Ewert was back in federal custody. In early November, McGill confirmed he was no longer enrolled.
I want to be upfront about what this episode is, and what it isn't.
I'm not here to tell you whether Jeffrey Ewert belongs in a law school classroom. That's a debate about rehabilitation, parole, and public safety, and it belongs to the people who are having it. What I can do is give you the part of the story most of the headlines skip over. What happened in 1984. How 2 cases with no obvious link were tied together. What a jury heard in 1986, what a judge heard in 1989, and what it cost the 2 families at the centre of it.
So that when you hear the name, you know the history.
This is a 2-part story. In Part One, we'll go back to 1984: the two attacks, the investigation that connected them, and the opening of Ewert's murder trial. In Part Two, we'll get to the verdict, a second trial, one family's fight to care for their daughter, and the latest on where things stand today.
I'm your host, Ryan Dell. This is Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime.
CHAPTER ONE: THE CHRONOLOGY
This story runs from 1984 to this fall, and it involves two criminal trials, a civil lawsuit, and an appeal. So before we get into it, let me lay it out in order.
February 12, 1984. A Langley teenager is attacked. Months later, Ewert will be charged with sexual assault causing bodily harm and attempting to choke her.
April 21, 1984. Another young woman is attacked in Langley. Ewert will later face identical charges for this one. The newspaper record I have doesn't tell us how either of these 2 charges was resolved, so I'm not going to say more than that.
May 7, 1984, evening. Corrina Makiev is at the Sneakers Cabaret in Langley.
May 8, 1984, around 2:30 am. She's seen walking near the Langley Provincial Court House.
May 8, 1984, just before noon. Her body is found in shallow water at the Barnston Island ferry slip in Surrey.
May 9, 1984. An autopsy puts her death somewhere between 2:30 am and 7:00 am that morning.
May 16, 1984. Surrey RCMP's Serious Crime Unit appeals to the public. No suspects.
June 16, 1984. A birthday party for Becky Ewert at her adoptive parents' home in Surrey. Kimberley Rendall, 15, is a guest. Around 2:00 am, she and 2 others go to sleep on sofas in the basement.
June 17, 1984, early morning. Kimberley is choked unconscious on the sofa and carried out of the house.
Around 7:00 am. Ewert's girlfriend finds him asleep, fully dressed, on her couch.
8:00 am. People in the Ewert house notice Kimberley is gone. There's blood on her pillow.
Around 9:30 am. Ewert comes back to his parents' house and puts that pillow in the washing machine.
Around 10:00 to 10:30 am. 2 children find Kimberley in a ditch near 158A Street and 112 Avenue.
July 10 and 11, 1984. RCMP investigators interview Ewert about the Rendall attack. He denies it.
July 11, 1984. Ewert makes his first court appearance on charges including attempted murder in the Rendall case. A 30-day psychiatric assessment is ordered. Bail is denied.
August 13, 1984. Ewert is charged with the first-degree murder of Corrina Makiev, along with charges for the February and April attacks.
September 17, 1984. In an interview with 2 Mounties, Ewert admits to both the Makiev killing and the Rendall attack.
April 1, 1986. His murder trial opens in B.C. Supreme Court in New Westminster.
April 17, 1986. The jury rejects his insanity defence. Guilty of first-degree murder. Life, no parole for 25 years.
June 1987. Kimberley's parents sue Ewert's parents. A jury finds the parents not liable.
December 1987. Kimberley, now 18, is eating on her own and attending high school for the first time since the attack.
September 15, 1989. Ewert is convicted of the attempted murder of Kimberley Rendall.
September 22, 1989. A second life sentence, to be served at the same time as the first.
October 1989. Ewert's appeal of his murder conviction is scheduled to be heard. This is where the newspaper clippings end.
December 2022. The Parole Board of Canada denies Ewert day parole.
July 2024. A Federal Court judge overturns that decision and sends it back to the board.
February 2025. Ewert is granted day parole after about 40 years in federal custody.
May 2025. His day parole is temporarily suspended after he contacts several women and collects their phone numbers, and a counsellor at his halfway house raises concerns about his attitude and behaviour.
June 2026. His day parole is extended for 6 months.
August 2026. He begins attending classes in McGill University's Faculty of Law.
Early October 2026. He stops appearing on campus.
Mid-October 2026. CBC News reports who he is. McGill announces it will review its admissions process.
Late October 2026. Correctional Service Canada issues a suspension warrant, and Ewert is returned to federal custody.
November 2, 2026. McGill tells students Ewert is no longer enrolled, and launches an independent review of its admissions process.
CHAPTER TWO: SNEAKERS
Corrina Makiev lived in Surrey. Some reports later called her a Langley woman, others a Cloverdale woman, which tells you how close those communities sat together in 1984. She was 19. Police said she was known to spend time in Langley's bars and nightclubs, and on the evening of Monday, May 7, she was at the Sneakers Cabaret.
So was Jeffrey Ewert.
Witnesses would later remember seeing him talking with her inside the club. According to testimony at his trial, she'd come with a date who left her there. Ewert told a friend afterward that she was wearing a dress and looking very good, which is about as much as he ever said about why he noticed her.
Sometime after the club, Corrina was walking home along the Fraser Highway, hitchhiking. Ewert pulled over and picked her up.
What happened next comes from 2 sources. The first is a set of formal admissions Ewert agreed to at his trial in 1986, which were read to the jury by the prosecutor. The second is his own testimony on the witness stand. They line up on the basic facts.
He drove her to a quiet spot in Surrey. She agreed to go. They parked, drank beer, listened to music, and talked. At some point he made a sexual advance, putting his hand on her leg. By his own account, she pushed his hand away and told him to drive her home.
He put his hands around her throat.
He choked her until she was unconscious. On the stand, he said he kept his hands there for 5 to 10 minutes. Then he pulled her out of the car and raped her while she was unconscious.
When he was finished, she didn't get up. He assumed she was dead.
He put her back in the car and drove to the Barnston Island ferry dock, on the south bank of the Fraser. He took her out of the car and threw her into the river. Then he drove away.
She was still alive when she went into the water. That was spelled out in the agreed facts filed in court: Corrina Makiev died in the river. When police first went public in May of 1984, they described her death as manual strangulation. By the time of trial, the account was that she'd been choked unconscious and drowned.
Ewert kept her purse. He also kept her high-heeled shoes, a white shawl, and her nylons. Later, he buried all of it in the yard behind the garage at his parents' place.
Hold on to that purse. It comes back.
Later that same morning, the truck driver found her. Police believed she'd been put into the river at the same spot where she was found, and on the same morning. Her last confirmed sighting was 2:30 am near the courthouse in Langley. The autopsy window ran from 2:30 am to 7:00 am.
The Surrey RCMP Serious Crime Unit published her description, gave out their phone number, and asked anyone who'd seen her that night to call. In the newspaper a week later, police said several people had been questioned. They had no suspects.
And Ewert went on with his life. He told a friend about it. He'd later testify that he managed to dismiss what he'd done as a mistake, and found he could live with himself.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: Let me tell you why this kind of case keeps investigators up at night. A woman meets a stranger at a bar. She leaves, she gets into a car on a highway at 2:30 in the morning, and the next time anyone sees her she's in a river. There's no relationship between victim and killer to work back from. No jealous boyfriend, no money dispute, no motive anyone can point to. The scene is a ferry slip where anybody could have parked. Water does terrible things to physical evidence, and in 1984 there was no DNA science to speak of. The Crown prosecutor said it plainly years later: when Corrina was recovered, police had very few clues, and Ewert wasn't on any list. In a case like that, your best hope is usually that the offender does something else, or tells someone. In this case, he did both.
CHAPTER THREE: THE BIRTHDAY PARTY
Kimberley Rendall was 15. A student at Cloverdale Junior Secondary. Her family described her as shy and blue-eyed. She played clarinet in school concerts. She and a girlfriend made up their own dance routines, and she'd taught herself to moonwalk. She wanted to be a jazz dancer. Her stepdad said her idea of a good meal was a huge platter of hamburgers, onion rings and fries. She loved her dog.
She was friends with Becky Ewert, Jeffrey's younger adoptive sister. On Saturday, June 16, 1984, Becky had a birthday party at the family home in Surrey, and Kimberley stayed over. Around 2:00 am, she and 2 others, Jeffrey's sister and her boyfriend, settled down to sleep on sofas in the basement.
Jeffrey Ewert, 22, didn't live there anymore. He'd been living away from home for about 6 months. That night he'd been out drinking at Sneakers, the same club, and he'd gone to see his girlfriend. They argued. She went to bed alone.
One more detail from that night, reported during his trial. Ewert was wearing a vest with the words "Boston Strangler" on it.
Sometime in the early hours, he went to his parents' house and down into the basement. What happened there was later set out in 5 pages of written admissions read to the jury in 1986.
He walked over to where Kimberley was sleeping and woke her up. When she woke, he started choking her. He choked her until she was unconscious. She bled, and the blood got on the sofa pillow and on his clothes.
The other 2 people in that basement were asleep on the next sofa. Close enough that Ewert would later describe them as not 5 feet away. Neither of them woke up.
He changed his clothes. Then he dragged Kimberley, still unconscious, out of the house to his car and pushed her through the hatchback. He drove to an isolated area near the intersection of 158A Street and 112 Avenue. When he pulled her out of the back of the car, her head struck the pavement. He dragged her to a ditch and rolled her into it.
And then he went back to his girlfriend's. At about 7:00 am, she found him asleep on her couch, fully dressed.
At 8:00 am, people in the Ewert house started looking for Kimberley. She was gone. There was blood on the pillow she'd been using.
At about 9:30 am, Jeffrey Ewert came home. He picked up that pillow and put it in the washing machine.
Sometime between 10:00 and 10:30 am, 2 children playing in the area found her. About 7 hours after she'd been put there, she was still in the ditch, wearing a hip-length blue nightie and a shirt, unconscious. Different papers placed the spot near the Surrey landfill, in dense bush in Fraser Heights, and in the Port Mann area. They're all describing the same corner of north Surrey.
She was taken to Royal Columbian Hospital. Her jaw was broken in 2 places. Her skull was fractured. But the worst of it was invisible. Being choked into unconsciousness had cut off the oxygen to her brain long enough to cause irreversible damage.
She went into a coma. The Crown counsel in that first court appearance told the judge her chances of survival were minimal.
She survived. But the Kimberley Rendall who loved to dance never came back.
CHAPTER FOUR: THE INTERVIEW ROOM
Kimberley had disappeared from inside the Ewert home. So the people connected to that home were the first ones investigators looked at, and Jeffrey Ewert came under suspicion almost immediately.
Constable Greg Johnson of Surrey RCMP spoke with him. Ewert said he'd been at Sneakers that night. Johnson wasn't satisfied with that account. And something about the name of that club stuck with him.
He went back through the files. Six weeks earlier, a 19-year-old woman named Corrina Makiev had been at Sneakers the night she disappeared, hitchhiking home along the Fraser Highway.
Investigators took a photo of Ewert to the club and showed it around. One patron remembered seeing him talking to Corrina Makiev the night she vanished.
That was it. No physical evidence. No witness to either attack. Just 2 files that touched the same nightclub, and a man who'd been in that nightclub both nights.
On July 10, 1984, Constables Hilary Perka and Greg Johnson sat down with Ewert. That interview was taped, and a little under 2 years later a jury heard the tape.
At this point, they were investigating the attack on Kimberley. They had their theory. Ewert had a row with his girlfriend, had some drinks, couldn't go back to her place, went home, and there was Kim, asleep on the sofa. All that frustration came out on the nearest, weakest person.
Johnson suggested the attack was so savage that, in the attacker's own mind, he wasn't beating Kim at all, but something or someone he hated. He brought up Ewert's difficult relationship with his mother. Ewert picked up on where that was going right away.
"You're suggesting a psychiatrist," he said.
Johnson said yes. He was suggesting Ewert needed help.
For most of an hour, Ewert said very little beyond "uh-hmm" and "yeah." He denied everything. When Johnson said it had to stop, and the only way to stop it was to identify who did it, Ewert answered, "Well, good luck." He said he had no idea who did it and didn't know anyone that violent. Eventually he conceded one thing. He agreed he had problems. When friends told him to see a psychiatrist, he said, he'd brushed it off, because he thought psychiatrists were for sick people.
Then comes a line that's hard to listen to now. Constable Perka, trying to lower the stakes, told him: "The thing is, you haven't killed anybody. Kim is still alive."
Perka didn't know. Nobody in that room except Ewert knew.
And Ewert pushed back with something just as strange in hindsight. Maybe if another one happens soon, he told them, they'd see something they missed the first time, and they'd realize they were looking for a guy who's done 20 of them, but they were talking to him instead.
The next interview ran into the early hours of July 11 and went on for close to 3 hours. This time Ewert talked. Not about the attack, but about his dreams.
He told the officers he'd had violent dreams for years. Dreams of tying people up. Dreams of stabbing people, especially his father, over and over. In other dreams he was a kind of comic book hero, part Conan the Barbarian, running through a forest with a sword. He said in his dreams he was so powerful nothing could hurt him.
He talked about his mother. He was adopted, part Cree, and he said his adoptive mother used a racial slur about his Indigenous background with such disgust that it made him angry. He said he felt she'd adopted him and then regretted it.
And then he started describing the attack on Kimberley as though it were one of those dreams. A dream of hitting someone, he said, and throwing them to the ground. Waking up with the feeling he'd done something awful to a weak person. A few nights after police first questioned him, another dream, of Kim pointing a finger at him.
Near the end of that interview, an officer slid a photograph across the table. It was Corrina Makiev.
"Is she dead?" Ewert asked.
The officer told him Cory had been found in the Fraser River. Same circumstances as Kim.
"Oh, no," Ewert said. He told them it was hard for him to accept he'd done these things. He said he'd always thought he was relatively normal.
Then came the second team.
Police ran two teams of interviewers against Ewert, alternating them. What the officers themselves would later call nice guy and nasty guy. Constable James Moore, led the aggressive side. Before he went in, the teams talked over what Moore would describe in court as Ewert's weak spots and tender spots.
Moore walked into the interview room just as Ewert was getting ready to leave, believing he was about to be released. Moore told him he had big problems, and that he'd just hit the big time.
Over about 2 and a half hours, Moore worked to build a bond. He told Ewert he had a degree in psychology. He told him he'd been sexually abused as a child himself. Neither was true, and Moore admitted that under oath. He said he was trying to build a connection.
It started working. Ewert broke down. He cried. He said he'd never done anything like this before, which, as we now know, was not true. He said the attack on Kim might have been an accident. He asked whether he'd get treatment. He said he didn't want to go to a federal prison as a sex offender because he believed he'd be killed there, and he asked if there was somewhere he could go to be treated.
He also asked to write a letter to Kimberley. In that July 1984 letter, he told her he might never get the chance to apologize in person and asked her to forgive him. He also asked that, if she had any doubt he was the one who did it, she say so when she was able.
Then Moore deliberately broke the bond he'd built. He told Ewert he'd lost all respect for him, that the dream story was an insult to his intelligence, and called him a pathetic liar and scum. Then he stormed out. The idea, he explained in court, was that Ewert would turn toward Johnson, the officer he seemed to like.
There was more. Officers told Ewert anything he said probably wouldn't be admissible in court. That wasn't true. They told him Kimberley had come out of her coma and could identify her attacker. That wasn't true either. Johnson arranged for another officer to interrupt an interview and hand Ewert a note telling him to call the hospital about Kimberley. Johnson left the note on the table, walked out, and when he came back, told Ewert she was awake and there was no need to talk anymore, because he knew for sure Ewert did it.
At one point, while questioning him about Kimberley, Moore suddenly produced a photo of Corrina Makiev's body. Ewert turned his face away and clawed at the wall.
Police drove him out to the ditch where Kimberley was found. He insisted he'd never been there.
On the basis of what he'd said in those early interviews, Ewert was charged in the Rendall case. But he hadn't confessed to anything. Not yet.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: I want to separate 2 things here, because the courts eventually did. The first is the Sneakers connection, and that's just good police work. A constable who isn't satisfied with an alibi, who remembers a detail from somebody else's file, who goes and checks, and who takes a photo to a bar to see if anyone recognizes the face. Nothing fancy. That's how a lot of cases get solved, and it's how this one started. The second thing is the interview strategy, and that's more complicated. Canadian courts have long accepted that police can use some trickery in an interview room. What they don't accept is an offer of a benefit in exchange for talking, because that can make a confession unreliable. Lying about having a psychology degree is one thing. Repeatedly suggesting that if a man admits it, he'll get psychiatric help instead of prison, is something else entirely. That distinction didn't sink this investigation. But as you'll hear, 5 years later it came within a whisker of sinking part of it.
CHAPTER FIVE: THE FRIENDS
Here's something the Crown made a point of at trial. Police had Ewert as a suspect in the Rendall attack because of where it happened. But according to the prosecutor, he wasn't linked to the Makiev murder in any solid way until he talked to a friend about it.
That friend was Glen DesRoches. They'd known each other since high school in Pemberton, where Ewert had gone to live with relatives as a teenager.
Sometime after Corrina's death, Ewert told DesRoches what happened. He described meeting her, picking her up, how she looked. He said the next thing he knew, he had his hands around her throat and she went limp. And while he was telling the story, DesRoches testified, Ewert put his hands around DesRoches's own neck to show him.
Ewert explained it away. He said he'd been really drunk, had snorted some cocaine, maybe smoked a couple of joints. He said he wasn't some kind of sicko running around killing people. He said he'd been possessed by an evil spirit, but it was gone now.
Glen DesRoches went to the police.
Later, Constable Johnson, now working with Constable Moore, put the friend's statement in front of Ewert. Johnson told the jury what Ewert said when he read it.
"Well, well, well, well. That says it all right there."
On August 13, 1984, Ewert was charged with first-degree murder. He was also charged in the February and April attacks in Langley.
And then, from his jail cell, he made the biggest mistake of the whole case.
He wrote a letter. 23 handwritten pages, to another longtime friend named Robert MacDonald.
The letter opens like a love letter between friends. You're my dearest friend, you're the only one who can help me, no one can see this but you. Then he gets to it. He admits he committed a murder. He says he's facing 25 years without parole, that his lawyers see no way out, and that he'd rather be dead than spend 25 years in prison.
Then he says he's devised a way out.
What follows is one of the most detailed pieces of evidence-tampering instructions I've ever seen in a Canadian case file. I'll walk you through it, because it's the plan that tells you the most about the man who wrote it.
Part one. He tells MacDonald he kept the girl's purse, and he's drawn a map to where it's buried behind his parents' garage. Use my father's long digging shovels, he writes, because they're the right length to measure it out. Almost 2 shovel lengths from the corner of the garage, a little more than 1 length out from the wall. Dig it up on a Sunday. Try not to be seen.
Then, wearing rubber gloves, wipe the fingerprints off everything inside, right down to her ID cards. Put it all in a box. Cut letters out of a newspaper or magazine and glue them to a page, so it looks like, in his words, a crazy person made it. The note should tell his parents this is the evidence they need to free their son. Leave the box on his parents' doorstep for them to find in the morning. And whatever you do, leave no prints.
The point, he explains, is that he's in jail. He couldn't have delivered it. So someone else must be the killer.
Part two is about explaining away what he'd said to Glen DesRoches.
Inside the envelope, he'd put 2 more blank sheets of paper with his own fingerprints already on them, each folded a different way. MacDonald was to glue cut-out letters onto them to make 2 fake threatening notes. One would tell Ewert to come to the pay phones at the Langley Safeway at 4:00 pm. The other would tell him to tell his friend Glen he'd strangled the girl, or else. The wording he wrote out for that second note is full of misspellings, including Glen's last name. The letter doesn't say whether that was deliberate.
Those notes were to be left in an old truck at the back of the family property, together with the high-heeled shoes that were buried with the purse. And the white shawl and the nylons that were also in the hole? Burn them, he wrote. They don't exist.
The cover story he planned to tell went like this. A week after the murder, he found a note and a pair of women's shoes in his car. He went to the phone booth at Safeway as instructed. A strange man on the line accused him of seeing something he shouldn't have, and threatened to frame him for the girl's death unless he did as he was told. That's why, the story went, he told Glen he'd strangled her. He'd been forced to.
He also gave MacDonald his explanation for the killing itself. He'd smoked half a joint one night, and his only conclusion was that it must have been laced with PCP, angel dust. He insisted he wasn't a killer and wasn't a rapist.
He ended by asking MacDonald to trust him, like Sundance trusted Butch Cassidy. No one would ever know he'd helped.
Robert MacDonald took the letter straight to the RCMP.
Police dug behind the garage. The articles were where the map said they would be.
POLICE PERSPECTIVE: Two things here. First, most of the cases I've seen solved weren't solved by a forensic breakthrough. They were solved because somebody the offender trusted decided they couldn't live with what they knew. Glen DesRoches and Robert MacDonald both did something genuinely hard. They turned in a friend. Neither of them had to, and the case against Ewert for the murder looks very different without them. Second, think about what that letter actually is. It's a man in custody, with nothing but time, building a multi-step plan to plant evidence, fake an alibi, manufacture threatening notes, and destroy what he considers the most incriminating items. He thinks about fingerprints. He thinks about fold lines. He thinks about who might see you digging. Every bit of that planning was designed to create doubt. Instead, it handed police the purse, the shoes, and a map to find them, and gave the Crown a 23-page written confession in his own handwriting. And when we get to the question of whether Ewert understood what he'd done was wrong, I want you to remember this letter, because the jury certainly did.
CHAPTER SIX: MURDERER OR MADMAN
The murder trial of Jeffrey George Ewert opened on Tuesday, April 1, 1986, in B.C. Supreme Court in New Westminster. Justice Ross Lander presided, with a jury of 7 men and 5 women. The Crown prosecutor was Rick Miller. Ewert was represented by Terry La Liberte.
And right away, the jury was handed something unusual.
Ewert pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder. But through his lawyer, he admitted he killed Corrina Makiev. The prosecutor read those admissions aloud: the club, the pickup on the Fraser Highway, the beer, the choking, the rape, the ferry dock.
Justice Lander could see the jurors trying to square that. A man admits he did it, but says he's not guilty? He told them they might be somewhat bewildered, and that the mental element of the case would become clear.
It became clear on day 2. La Liberte stood up and told the jury, so there wouldn't be any confusion, that the main defence was insanity.
So nobody in that courtroom was arguing about who killed Corrina Makiev. The entire trial was about one question. What was going on in Jeffrey Ewert's mind when he did it?
The Crown's case
The Crown called Glen DesRoches and Robert MacDonald. Constable Johnson read the 23-page letter to the jury.
Then the Crown did something that told you how it planned to win. It introduced what lawyers call similar fact evidence. Normally, a jury trying someone for one crime doesn't get to hear about other crimes. But a judge can let it in when it's relevant to a real issue in the case, beyond just showing the accused is a bad person. Here, the Crown wanted the jury to hear about Kimberley Rendall. Justice Lander allowed it and told the jury its purpose would become clear.
Ewert agreed to another 5 pages of admissions, this time about the Rendall attack. The jury heard about the basement, the pillow, the hatchback, the ditch. And they heard the Crown's position on why he did it.
That came through Constable Johnson. He testified that once Ewert finally talked, he explained why he went after Kimberley. He said he'd shaken her shoulder to wake her, and she woke up looking frightened. He said he couldn't believe it, that she had no reason to be afraid of him.
And on seeing that fear in her eyes, he decided he had to kill her. If he didn't, she might tell her parents about his advances. They'd think he was some kind of pervert and call the police. The police would investigate him, and they'd find out about Corrina Makiev.
So he had to kill her, to avoid being discovered.
Johnson said Ewert told him it was really wild doing it right there, with his sister and her boyfriend asleep not 5 feet away. He said Ewert described it as if his hands were acting on their own, independent of his mind and body. He said Ewert told him the experience of killing the first woman helped him with the second, and that once you've killed, it's easy to kill again.
And Johnson told the jury that when Ewert was finally charged, he patted him on the shoulder and said, "Way to go, guys. You did it."
The jury also heard from an undercover RCMP constable who had posed as a fellow prisoner in Ewert's cell after his arrest. That officer testified Ewert told him he couldn't remember attacking the girl.
And they heard the interrogation tapes. The dreams. The sword. The comment about his mother. The photograph of Corrina. Constable Moore was cross-examined about his lies, his insults, and the breaking-down process, and he admitted all of it.
The accused takes the stand
On April 10, Ewert testified in his own defence.
He told the jury about the evil spirit. He said it first visited him years before the killing. One paper reported he said it came when he was 14. Another reported it as 7 years before 1984. Either way, he described waking up unable to move, sensing something 3-dimensional in the room, until he forced himself to shout that he was awake.
Then, he said, it came back months before the murder, while he was in bed with his girlfriend, Margaret. The air turned cold and thick. He woke unable to breathe for several minutes and checked to see if he'd swallowed his tongue. And then, he said, Margaret woke up wide-eyed, and told him she'd had the same dream. A shadow came into the room and put a bony hand over his mouth.
He talked about his mother's manic depression and her stays at Riverview Hospital. As a kid, he said, he never knew what was wrong with her. In his mind, she was crazy. He said he started drinking and smoking marijuana at 16, and alcohol became a crutch. He admitted a conviction for having 5 grams of marijuana, and a mischief conviction from when he was high on LSD. He told a story about getting locked in the Pacific Coliseum with a road crew after a ZZ Top concert and smashing a window because he thought they were going to kill him.
Then his lawyer took him to May 8, 1984.
Hunched in the witness box, hands clenched, sobbing at times, he described the hand on her leg, the rejection, and what happened next. Before he could stop himself, he said, his hands were around her throat. He described a surge of energy through his whole body, almost like a buzz, a feeling of release. He said he couldn't stop, and that if he could have, he would have.
Asked about Kimberley, he said the same thing happened. The same surge. His hands darting out.
He said he knew saying sorry didn't make up for it. If someone came to him and said they were sorry they'd strangled his daughter, he told the jury, he'd spit in their face. Sorry, he said, is what you say when you spill somebody's drink.
The cross-examination
The next day, Rick Miller went after him.
He got Ewert to agree that he isn't an alcoholic. Isn't a drug addict. Doesn't have epilepsy. Had never needed psychiatric help before.
Then Miller asked him directly whether raping and killing Corrina Makiev gave him pleasure.
Ewert said no.
Miller asked whether he attacked Kimberley Rendall because he wanted to feel that buzz again. That rush of pleasure.
Ewert said no.
The experts
The defence called one expert, a psychologist named Dr. Peggy Koopman. She testified Ewert was above average in general ability, language skills, and reasoning. She described him as a storehouse of anger, rejection and resentment. Her diagnosis was a condition called episodic discontrol, meaning recurring attacks of uncontrollable rage. In her opinion it amounted to a disease of the mind. When alcohol and drugs lowered his inhibitions, she said, forces inside him that he wasn't even aware of took over, and he was more of an observer than an actor.
Miller suggested she liked Ewert and had conjured up a diagnosis to fit the legal test for insanity. She told him that came a little too close to questioning her ethics, and she took exception. Miller put it to her that Ewert was an evil con man who'd pulled the wool over her eyes.
The Crown called 3 experts in reply. Dr. Clifford Kerr, a forensic psychiatrist, said Ewert was a psychopath, a man incapable of remorse or shame, and legally sane. Dr. Michael Coles, a forensic psychologist, said the evidence showed Ewert was fully in control when he choked Corrina because she turned him down, and that he threw her in the river to destroy evidence. Dr. Philip Adilman, also a forensic psychiatrist, said Ewert didn't suffer from a mental illness. He had a personality disorder, and he was legally sane.
Closing
In closing, La Liberte reminded the jury that the only real issue was Ewert's state of mind, and that the defence only had to prove insanity on a balance of probabilities, not beyond a reasonable doubt.
Miller told the jury that Ewert would blame anything and anyone to escape the consequences. Alcohol. Drugs. His mother. Evil spirits. Mental illness. He pointed back to Ewert's own statement about the pleasure he felt, and to the line about it being really wild with his sister asleep 5 feet away. In Miller's words, it was the statement of a cold-blooded killer describing a killing he enjoyed.
At 3:00 pm on Wednesday, April 16, the jury went out.
END OF PART ONE
That jury had to answer a question that sounds simple and isn't. Not whether Jeffrey Ewert killed Corrina Makiev. He'd admitted that. The question was whether, in the eyes of the law, he knew what he was doing, and knew it was wrong.
In Part Two, I'll break down what that question really meant, walk through the evidence that answered it, and tell you what the jury decided. Then we'll follow Kimberley Rendall's family into a courtroom of their own, watch a second trial come close to falling apart over how a confession was taken, and bring the story right up to this month, when Ewert was returned to federal custody and McGill confirmed he's no longer enrolled.
To every first responder listening, the ones who carry calls like these home with them: thank you. What you do costs something real, whether anyone sees it or not.
If you liked what you heard, please take a moment to give the show a 5-star review. It helps other people find these stories. And if there's a case you think I should cover, send me an email. My address is: canadiancrimecast@gmail.com.
I'm Ryan Dell, and this is Canadian CrimeCast: Coast to Coast True Crime.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Canadian True Crime
Kristi Lee